ROS with Kubernetes #2

revised from ROS with Kubernetes.

I am glad to announce 2nd ROS with Kubernetes Meeting at 2023-01-18T18:00:00Z.

many thanks to @mhl787156 to give us a talk about ROS with Kubernetes use case, he also talked about this at ROSCon 2022 LT.

If you are interested or related talks, please join us!!!

thanks
Tomoya

8 Likes

We are trying to make sure if there could be more talks available at ths time, i will come up agenda soon.

If you are interested and dont want to miss it, please PM me, so that i can send you the invitation for the meetup.

thanks

Date

2023-01-18T18:00:00Z

Agenda

  • Kubernetes and ROS 2 for Local Multi UAV Development by @mhl787156 (20mins)
  • Introduction and Demonstration robolaunch by @Mukremin_Cetinkaya (20mins)
  • QA / Discussion (10min)

Join Meeting

thanks
Tomoya

8 Likes

Hi @tomoyafujita,

unfortunately I most likely won’t be able to attend live. Would it be possible to record and share the meeting, because the topics are very interesting.

Kind regards,
Gergely

1 Like

hmmm, I am unable to record the meeting… if someone else can facilitate this meeting with recording, that would be really helpful.

2nd ROS with Kubernetes meeting will be starting in 1 hour !!! Please feel free to join us :smile:

Thanks for the organizing the discussion. It was great.

@Mukremin_Cetinkaya I’m wondering if your solution supports the robots/remote devices that are behind carrier grade NAT?

1 Like

Note is here, ROS with Kubernetes - Google Docs

2 Likes

@mhl787156 @Mukremin_Cetinkaya thank you so much for the talk !!! sorry we did not have enough time for the QA, let’s follow up some questions via this thread.

and if possible, could you share the slide deck that you used today? that would be really helpful.

1 Like

i was going to ask the same question. what i see from architecture diagram is kubernetes cluster control-plane connected with VPN.

@mhl787156 about the discovery server user-experience problem, probably we can use kubernetes service discovery, not application runtime layer. using headless service for discovery server, and describe that service information in deployment, that would work. in that case, user application does not really need to know anything about this, but can use service discovery.

Thanks for joining also. Yes definitely support robots behind any kind of NAT. VPN is automatically deployed and we have already tested in wifi and 4G/5G networks also different cloud providers.

@tomoyafujita oh that sounds like a good idea, so far i’ve tried to use kubernetes as is (the hurdles of doing anything remotely complex are daunting!) but if we could wrap the discovery server as a kubernetes service discovery mechanism that would be really neat. It would solve a whole bunch of networking problems too!

This combined with Custom Resource Definitions, it almost sounds like we should be building a ROS dedicated kubernetes stack, instead of simply using k8s!

Thanks again for the invite to talk!

1 Like

If we use ROS 1, there will rosmaster required in the system, that is the same exact problem here. I think i can come up with some example how to describe the yaml file using headless service.

My presentation is here for future reference :slight_smile: : Nextcloud
Was the presentation recorded in the end?

@tomoyafujita the only sad thing is that we end up reverting back to the ROS1 way of doing things. This really is the downside of doing full multi-robot ROS2 applications! However as mentioned I think what zenoh is doing is a good middleground - I wonder if zenoh could be wrapped as a kube service

Was the presentation recorded in the end?

No sorry, i was unable to do that. If we have next time, i will set this up for sure.

the only sad thing is that we end up reverting back to the ROS1 way of doing things.

correct, once we have a server, that could be a single point failure, not distributed system anymore.
but i think that depends on use case and requirement, besides we can make it high reliability with backup server.

Here is the slide deck for robolaunch.

@Mukremin_Cetinkaya thank you so much for the talk and information.